The Perfect Plate – December 2024
Every month, we’ll provide updates on the latest trends in the restaurant industry. We’ll include financial insights, charts, and public market comps.
If you are a hospitality investor or interested in learning more about investing in restaurants & hospitality – subscribe to access private offerings from our select clients.
2025 Planning
Overall optimistic business environment in the US with foundations set for 2026 onwards
Impact of Strong Economic Growth on the U.S. Restaurant Industry
1. Increased Consumer Spending
- Effect on Restaurants: With GDP growing at an annualized rate of 3.2% and consumer sentiment at its highest since early 2022, diners are likely to spend more on discretionary activities, including eating out. This trend benefits both fast-casual and fine-dining restaurants, as consumers feel confident in splurging on dining experiences. Chains could see higher foot traffic, particularly during weekends and holidays.
- Implication: Restaurants may need to scale up inventory, staff, and promotional efforts to capitalize on increased demand.
2. Opportunities for Expansion and Investment
- Effect on Restaurants: A strong economy, buoyed by a solid job market and low unemployment (3.6%), encourages businesses to invest in growth. For restaurant operators, this could mean opening new locations, upgrading technology, or enhancing customer experiences. Investors may also see the restaurant industry as a lucrative sector, leading to increased funding for expansion or innovation.
- Implication: New entrants and innovations in the market could increase competition, pushing existing players to differentiate themselves.
3. Impact of Rising Treasury Yields
- Effect on Restaurants: Higher yields on the 10-year Treasury signal reduced the likelihood of aggressive Fed rate cuts. While this may not directly affect consumers, it could impact restaurant operators relying on loans for expansion, as borrowing costs are likely to remain elevated.
- Implication: Restaurants might focus more on optimizing operations and cutting costs instead of pursuing aggressive growth, especially smaller operators with tighter margins.
4. Shifts in Consumer Preferences for Riskier Investments
- Effect on Restaurants: With strong economic growth prompting consumers and investors to lean toward riskier opportunities, premium dining experiences or trendy restaurant concepts could gain popularity. This creates a favorable environment for innovative or experiential dining options to thrive.
- Implication: Restaurants should consider incorporating unique or upscale offerings to attract consumers willing to spend on memorable experiences.
Continued Shift to Off-Premises Delivery and Takeout: 2025 Outlook Across Restaurant Segments
The restaurant industry continues to evolve as off-premises delivery, takeout, and curbside pickup remains a key revenue driver across all segments. The use of in-house and on-platform technology to bypass third-party delivery commissions is gaining traction as brands aim to protect margins and maintain control over the customer experience. Here’s how this trend is shaping the future of various segments in 2025:
Quick-Service Restaurants (QSR)
2025 Outlook:
QSR brands are expected to deepen their investment in proprietary ordering platforms and loyalty apps to strengthen direct consumer relationships. Large players like McDonald’s and Taco Bell have already established robust digital ecosystems, including order-ahead features and personalized deals via mobile apps. These strategies reduce dependency on third-party platforms and increase profitability by cutting out commission fees.
- Key Drivers: The continued demand for speed and convenience makes QSRs particularly suited for app-based ordering and integrated drive-thru pickup. Additionally, partnerships with delivery services may persist but on more favorable terms for large brands due to their scale.
- Challenges: Smaller QSR chains may struggle with the upfront costs of developing proprietary technology, potentially slowing their ability to compete with larger players.
Fast Casual
2025 Outlook:
Fast-casual chains like Sweetgreen and Panera Bread are heavily focusing on enhancing their digital infrastructure, with a particular emphasis on loyalty programs and seamless in-app ordering experiences. These investments aim to capture the growing segment of consumers preferring takeout or delivery without the additional costs associated with third-party platforms. Companies like Owner are helping earlier stage brands to create proprietary mobile App and website in-house capabilities. They also have an amazing YouTube channel with valuable insights and resources. #notsponsored.
- Key Drivers: Consumers in this segment value convenience and customization, making the adoption of technology essential for maintaining competitiveness. Delivery lockers and geofencing for curbside pickup are emerging as additional innovations in this space.
- Challenges: Fast-casual chains must balance convenience with the perception of high-quality, fresh food, as this segment typically competes on both product quality and service innovation.
Upscale Casual
2025 Outlook:
Upscale casual restaurants are gradually adopting in-house delivery and takeout solutions to protect their brand image and service standards. Technology such as integrated POS systems and branded delivery apps allows these restaurants to offer a curated experience, even for off-premises orders.
- Key Drivers: Upscale casual diners expect a consistent experience, whether dining in or ordering out. Packaging innovations and personalized touches, such as handwritten notes or exclusive offers for direct orders, will play a key role in enhancing customer satisfaction.
- Challenges: The higher cost of ingredients and more labor-intensive menu items may make achieving profitability in off-premises channels more challenging compared to QSR or fast casual.
Fine Dining
2025 Outlook:
Fine dining establishments are cautiously entering the off-premises market, often targeting special occasions or high-end customers seeking restaurant-quality meals at home. While some brands have resisted this shift to preserve exclusivity, others are experimenting with premium meal kits or white-glove delivery services using in-house staff to maintain control over quality.
- Key Drivers: The ability to extend their brand experience beyond the dining room offers fine dining restaurants a way to capture incremental revenue, especially during slower in-person dining periods.
- Challenges: Maintaining the integrity of dishes designed for an in-house experience is a significant hurdle. Additionally, the cost of packaging and delivery logistics can be prohibitive without a high enough order volume.
Broader Implications for the Industry
The growing emphasis on bypassing third-party platforms signals a critical shift in how restaurants across all segments engage with off-premises customers. Restaurants that successfully integrate proprietary technology will likely see stronger profit margins, increased customer loyalty, and greater control over branding. However, smaller operators and those with limited resources may face difficulties keeping pace, potentially leading to further consolidation within the industry.
Highlights from 2024 Q4 Earnings Calls
Recent earnings calls from top publicly traded restaurant brands have highlighted several pivotal trends shaping the industry.
Emphasis on value offerings amidst consumer spending constraints
Many restaurant chains are doubling down on value-driven menus to attract cost-conscious consumers amid ongoing economic pressures. McDonald’s, after initially lagging behind competitors in this area, has reinforced the importance of these initiatives. The company has seen positive comparable sales growth, driven by successful campaigns like the $5 Meal Deal. Such promotions resonate with budget-conscious customers, ensuring steady foot traffic and brand loyalty during challenging times. This strategic pivot underscores the growing importance of offering affordable, high-perceived-value options in maintaining competitiveness and relevance in the marketplace.
Shifts in consumer behavior impacting sales mix
Changes in consumer spending habits, driven by macroeconomic factors, are reshaping the sales dynamics within restaurants. Texas Roadhouse, for instance, has reported a notable decline in alcohol sales, traditionally a high-margin category. This shift suggests that diners are prioritizing essential menu items over discretionary purchases, signaling a broader move toward more cost-conscious dining behavior. As alcohol sales decline, restaurants may face challenges in maintaining overall profitability and may need to explore other revenue streams or menu adjustments to offset the loss of these higher-margin items.
Public Market Top 10 for the Week
Starbucks leads the top 10 for the week ending Friday, 27 December 2024.
Public Market Summary for YTD Returns
Our Top Article Choices
- 8 restaurant trends to watch in 2025 – Link
- Restaurant Industry in Review: November 2024 Restaurant Trends – Link
- Restaurant Business – 6 menu trends that rocked restaurants in 2024 – Link
- Toast Data: Reservation trends shift to slower days and early dinners – Link
- WSJ – Are value meals worth it for restaurants? – Link
Market Update: Public Comps
Week Ending | 2024/12/27
Top 10 Monthly Price Movements
The last 30-day performance had an average of 0.9% for the Top 10.
Top 10 Enterprise Value [EV] / NTM Revenue Multiples
The top 10 is made up of mostly Franchisor entities, which have higher multiples than company owned concepts. Consensus revenue growth forecasts estimate ~14% growth into 2025. The growth guidance is attributable to store growth and price increases.
Public Comps – Trends
Trend – Enterprise Value [EV] / LTM Revenue Multiples
Trend – Enterprise Value [EV] / LTM EBITDA Multiples
Revenue Multiple Trends
Restaurant businesses are generally valued on multiples of their revenue or EBITDA, depending on their capital structure, growth potential, and franchise model. For example, a McDonald’s franchise has a higher revenue multiple than a company-owned restaurant chain like Shake Shack.
Here are some of the factors that affect restaurant valuation multiples:
- Capital structure: Businesses with less debt and more equity tend to have higher valuation multiples.
- Growth potential: Businesses with high growth potential tend to have higher valuation multiples.
- Franchise model: Franchise businesses tend to have higher valuation multiples than company-owned businesses.
EBITDA Multiple Trends
Sources
TIKR
Bloomberg
Company 10-Q and 10-K Filings
Restaurant Business
Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) [bls.gov]
U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) [bea.gov]
U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Economic Research Service [ers.usda.gov]
Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) [fred.stlouisfed.org]
National Restaurant Association [restaurant.org]
International Monetary Fund (IMF) [imf.org]
Disclaimer
The information provided is believed to be from reliable sources, but no liability is accepted for any inaccuracies. This is for information purposes and should not be construed as an investment recommendation. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance.
This post and the information presented are intended for informational purposes only. The views expressed herein are the author’s alone and do not constitute an offer to sell, or a recommendation to purchase, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security, nor a recommendation for any investment product or service. While certain information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, neither the author nor any of his employers or their affiliates have independently verified this information, and its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. Accordingly, no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to, and no reliance should be placed on, the fairness, accuracy, timeliness, or completeness of this information. The author and all employers and their affiliated persons assume no liability for this information and no obligation to update the information or analysis contained herein in the future.